Teaching My Baby To Read

Home » Education about Education » Alternate Day Kindergarten » My Beef with Alternate Day Kindergarten

My Beef with Alternate Day Kindergarten

Like school districts everywhere, our own school district has had to make some tough choices this year in order to operate on budget.  So starting last September, our district moved to an alternating day Kindergarten schedule in order to save money by not driving the Kindergarten half day bus.  I forget the exact number, but this decision saved around $180,000.
Alternate day schedule means that Bruce goes to school all day on Tuesdays, Thursdays, and about one Friday a month.  The alternative was to pay $3,000 and have Bruce go to school every day, all day, in the full day Kindergarten class next door.  We chose not to go this route, even though we could have afforded the tuition, because I was worried that Bruce would become bored and disruptive, since most of the Kindergarten academic curriculum doesn’t meet his needs to begin with.
Here are some of the many problems with the alternate day system.  By design, you have all of the families who can afford to pay $3,000 in one class, and the families that cannot afford this payment, plus the stay-at-home-mom families, in the other.  In the full day class next door, you have kids where all of the families could afford to pay $3,000, plus a number of children who are in daycare.  This is a very bizare dichotomy to have in a public school setting.
Then there is the issue of the alternating day schedule itself, or as my husband calls it “School once in a while.”  When you add in snow days, holidays, inservice days, and your kid staying home occasionally because he is sick, then you have a schizophrenic schedule which makes teaching kids the basics enormously difficult.  Keeping kids on a regular sleep and wake up schedule is also nearly impossible.  Why bother waking Bruce up at 6:45 each morning if he sometimes goes as long as eleven days between school?
Bruce’s teacher is caring, intuitive, and calm in the face of a very challenging situation.  When I have been in the classroom volunteering I have seen her teach quality lessons, that are designed to be very effective indeed.  But when kids are only attending school once in a while, how much can you do?
If the school district is going to stick with this alternating day schedule, then I think the district should start equipping parents to become de facto home-school teachers on the off days.  There could be optional actives, lessons, and homework packets for the children to complete on Mondays and Wednesday.  This model is being successfully used at a Charter school in Southern California that my cousin’s daughter attends . 
Coming from California, the alternating day schedule makes even less sense to me, because when I attended school busing was unavailable, unless your were being integrated across town.  So the idea of a busing schedule causing a district to make crucial decisions that adversely effect learning, seems ridiculous.  But I understand that our district has tough choices to make this year, and I very much respect our school district leaders and their integrity.  

1 Comment

  1. Claire H. says:

    I actually would like to have an option for alternate day kindergarten because I think that 5 days per week is a lot for young kids to be in an institutional setting. I like the “university model” found in certain private schools, where K is 2 days/week, 1st & 2nd is 3 days/week, and 3rd-5th is 4 days/week. But I think a part-time schedule should be an option available for parents to choose, not the default because of budget cuts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow me on Twitter